Critical Hope

"For Marx, Freire, and the twentieth-century existentalist psychologists, it is in the realm of consciousness that the contradiction between freedom and determinism is overcome.  While consciousness and life activity are determined by material conditions, a person who has no consciousness of self, who has nothing but life activity, is completely propelled by social forces.  But the person who is aware of these forces and conscious of their nature is able to break with the trajectory of history and participate in the radical change of self and society."

- From "A Primer of Libertarian Education" by Joel Spring

For critical hope - the hope for another world, the hope for an end to a culture of violent individualism and fear - there is a necessity to pay attention, to stay woke, and to strategically go to the places on the outside of the mainstream narrative and do the lord’s work, that humanizing kind of work where we lose our lives in order to find them. “‘The unexamined life is not worth living’ and ‘the examined life is painful’” (Socrates and Malcolm X told through educator and writer, Jeff Duncan-Andrade).  I remind myself often that the old-timers despaired probably as much or more as I do now at the state of the world when the US invaded Afghanistan and Iraq.  I was only becoming aware of the world then, but I remember the rage of my older activist friends.  At the same time, I think the current day is a pretty unique and frightful reality.  Twitter doesn’t help - with more information comes more vexation.  Bombs, Trump, white supremacists, troops on the border, huge lottery jackpots, too many flavors of beer, memes, Marvel movies, climate change, ad infinitum…

What is required is a simultaneous rejection of despair and cheap optimism, a courageous and love-filled facing of the social forces that drive our material existence, and an affinity for the solidarity work that takes us outside our comfort zone to the marginalized places all over the globe in order to do the necessary work to struggle for equity, justice, peace and dignity.

Early Notes on National Capitalism

Trump is a nationalist.  He’s urging his folks to use that word.  His nationalism is a response to a notion of ‘globalism,’ or ‘globalization.’  Back in the early 2000s globalization was the enemy of the radical Left.  Globalization and the neoliberal, state-sponsored capitalism that was engulfing the globe in multinational corporate expansion.  Globalization was what every mass protest from Seattle to Miami was rallying against.  The anti-globalization movement didn’t want US companies moving production overseas to exploit the global poor.  The anti-globalization movement didn’t want predatory banks and international lenders doing the same to poor countries as the predatory lenders were doing to poor homeowners in the US before the bubble burst.  The anti-globalization movement of yesteryear wanted international solidarity, environmental regulations to stave off mining, foresting, drilling, and other Earth-destroying activities, and the end to multi-national predatory capitalism and finance.  

Now Trump is a nationalist because ‘globalism’ is bad.  Somehow the moderate and radical Right have co-opted the global economic justice movement of the Left and turned it into the momentum behind national capitalism. 

I don’t use that term lightly.  I also recognize the contradictions when the president of the US espousing an ideology of nationalism since the US (including its multinational affiliates) is the economic and political empire of the day.  How can the US power structures believe in nationalism when it’s the exploitation of the entire planet that has provided this country with so much wealth throughout the last 500 years?

The anti-globalization movement hoped for another world, a world where wealth and power were distributed equally across the globe and across local communities in order to combat the ever-increasing centralization of wealth and power in the hands of the few.  The anti-globalization movement valued the diversity of local communities and sought to empower their unique solutions to problems facing us as humans.  The anti-globalization movement recognized the contradiction that multi-national corporations had access to move capital and production centers across borders, but poor people of the world were not allowed the same freedom of movement.  But Trump and the radical Right have now co-opted the discontent with the world we live in and are offering a terrifying, authoritarian solution in the form of national capitalism.

We can identify some of the tenants of Trump’s national capitalism in a few broad strokes: 1) the vilification and inhuman treatment of migrants, 2) the deregulation of environmental policies, 3) the consistent reliance on the war manufacturing sector of the US economy, 4) the continued structuring of wealth and power in the hands of a few, and 5) the sinister motto of “profit above all else.”

Trump was a capitalist.  Now he’s a proud national capitalist.  Let’s do ourselves a favor and not call the American fascists "nazis" (national socialists), but the more apt term "national capitalists."  Once we recognize this threat facing humanity we can begin to talk about constructive and creative ways to empower democracy, ensure the dignity of all people, and redistribute wealth and power in the world.  Or at the very least resist fascism in the USA.

Bring on the End

The end of a matter is better than its beginning, and patience is better than pride (Ecclesiastes 7:8).

Years ago, I rallied around this Old Testament verse after watching HBO’s detective drama True Detectives.  After eight, hour-long episodes, I was relieved that the dark Louisiana drama was over.  It made it better.  It made it ephemeral.

Originally, corporations, limited-liability companies, were not immortal institutions able to accumulate huge amounts of wealth and power.  Municipalities or local governments would task a group of people to build a bridge or work on a specific task, and after the job was done, the corporation would be dissolved.  And in a sick twist of political maneuvering, corporations jumped on the 14^th Amendment, the Amendment passed to protect the rights of freed enslaved persons, and now, arguably, Amazon, Apple, Google, Facebook, and the like have more protections, allowances, and power under the law than the people of the United States, and in certain arenas, the United States government.

Returning to the Old Testament, comes the often overlooked portion of Leviticus that redistributes the wealth and property of Israel because private property is a delusion when everything under the sun belongs to God.  The biblical law of Jubilee requires all lands to be returned, persons (sold into servitude) to be released, and all debts to be forgiven.  The unbridled accumulation of wealth and power through generations is a terrible idea, but essentially the founding idea of this nation. 

The end of something is better than the beginning.  It allows us time to reset.  To redistribute wealth and power.  To reflect on the decisions made individually and collectively in our lives and societies. 

Yes, I’m talking about the end of capitalism.  Of the American Empire.

This requires responsibility and patience – responsibility for ourselves and our neighbors, and patience with the messy and slow-moving pace of peace, justice and equity work.  But that’s the work that needs to be done.  It’s pride and greed that drives Trump to slap his name on every hideous thing his family’s estate has built.  It’s pride and greed that drives the American war hawks and profiteers into every corner of the globe.  It’s pride and greed that created 24-hour news media with it’s endless jabbering and political catering.  It's pride and greed that motivates the Democrats and Republicans to not take any serious measure to combat the slow apocalypse of climate change.  It’s pride and greed and institutions with no end in sight. 

I’m looking to the end of capitalism for the sake of the planet.

 

The Harvest Is Coming, or No More Special Forces

Yesterday, Buzzfeed published a terrifying article describing the role of US special forces operatives being hired out by private companies to do the whims of foreign governments.  The United States is already the biggest exporter of weapons and other military technologies.  Now, as was the logical conclusion of the evil empire, the US is servicing foreign governments by providing a pool of mercenaries to do what they’re trained for: killing humans.  The United States is sowing some seriously destructive and violent seeds that will only bloom into fatal fruits.

The economy of our evil empire is supported largely by defense spending, weapons manufacturing, and technologies developed originally by research and development (R&D) grants paid for by the military.  This is what it means to be a warfare state.  This is why the United States is still at war in Afghanistan going on eighteen years (as well as to train more US Special Forces operatives).  The wars we fight today are not the wars of the past.  Unmanned drones piloted by a person hundreds or thousands  of miles away drop bombs on people who have no way of defending themselves.  If not drones, then special forces operatives – the guys they make movies about, they idolize in first person shooter video games, the guys that are so willing to serve their country that they train for years in the art of ending human life.  That gamut of training and preparing to be the most effective killing machine in the world is not a humanizing endeavor.  No one is advocating the pleasantness, goodness, or positive impact of those that work Special Forces.  At best, the argument goes that they’re defending our freedoms [sic] as Americans or that the enemy whom their killing is a depraved, soulless entity.  But the entire reason for being for a Special Forces operative is to effectively neutralize targets, or in other words: end human life.  I don’t sympathize with evil people regardless of what country they were born in, but dedicating oneself to the art, science, production, or profiting from the murder of others is a tragic and loathsome offense.

Violence and war is the option after creativity and dignity have been abandoned and that is exactly what the US is reaping with the current state of affairs.  We have abandoned dignity by allowing so many killing machines be allowed out of our borders to be used for their one intended purpose all around the world.  We have abandoned creativity by allowing the easy, deplorable, and effective solution of violence to dominate our actions in the face of conflict and problems.  We need a change of course.  We need to end the violence perpetuated, exported, and designed by our government.  We need to defund the Pentagon.  Bring the troops home.  Heal them.  Teach them and our collective sense of right and wrong that it is not honorable to pull triggers or drop bombs.  For a peaceful future we’re going to need, not only to radically transform the mechanisms and values of our society, but also suspend the atrocious nature of training and supporting troops that specialize in murder.  Conflict can escalate or de-escalate.  The former is the path to death while the latter is the path to peace.  It’s time to sow seeds of peace because the harvest is coming.

Another World is Possible

My favorite panel from Bill Watterson was refurnished as a primitive meme.  It portrays Calvin at the dinner table with his mom. On the left of the frame, Calvin's mom - eyes lowered to her plate - says, "Things could be worse, Calvin."  To the right of the frame, Calvin is leaning over his plate proclaiming loudly, "Life could be a lot better, too!"

I came out of the 2000s with a crash course in radicalism and revolutionary politics.  At the current rate of the world, I'm going to come out of the 2010s with a crash course in dystopian realities, Twitter induced anxieties, and the glitter and doom of climate change. 

"For with much wisdom comes much sorrow; the more knowledge, the more grief" (Ecclesiastes 1:18).  There is another world on its way, if we take it from Arundhati Roy, and listen very carefully we can hear her breathe on a quiet day.  But quiet days are few and far between in the current state of the world.  Quiet days are a privilege for the disconnected, the book readers, the hikers, and some city street walkers.  Turbulence is the defining atmosphere of our era.  Hot air colluding with frightened humans concerned about the state of their property and privilege, and willing to submit to the storm of too much work for too little play, too much fear for too little love, too many mechanisms for too few outlets for human creativity.

I'm a product of radical social, political, and economic criticism in the era of radical access to information.  Thank God for the journalists that are willing to tell the truth, to paint narratives of the sick realities of the world, and to incite others to realize that, left unattended, the rich and powerful resemble a conceiving beast backed into a corner by its own shadow.  But the rank-and-file realities of those living in the United States cannot escape the insidious nature of the white supremacist, capitalist patriarchy.  I'm serious.  The United States is reaping what it sowed when Columbus set foot on this land and deemed the other humans worthy of enslavement.  We didn't get a say in what Columbus or the other colonizers did, but we're feeling the effects everyday when we go to school, go to work, go to the store, go to the glowing screen.

I will never blame anyone for not paying attention unless I know them.  Paying attention to the state of the world is a buzzkill that, done incorrectly, can lead directly to the fourth stage of grief. 

But listen...to a quiet day.  Then come back and recognize that those that deny alternatives for how the world could be, and those that deem any changes to society as terrible transgressions, know that those uncreative nay-sayers are simply full of hot air and fear. 

It's not great believing authoritarianism, the climate, ignorance, and social/political/economic problems are on the rise, but it's the only world we've got.  And in this world, as a human endowed with dignity, there is that voice that echos Calvin at the dinner table - discontent with the way things are - that must remind us everyday that things could be a lot better too, that there are alternatives to life as we know it, that another world is possible.